Shut SMS #208


Ha-Rav answers hundreds of text message questions a day!  Here's a sample:

Gemara Learning in Korea

Q: In South Korea, there is much interest in learning Gemara.  Is this worthwhile?

A: Certainly not.  It is forbidden to teach Torah to non-Jews and it is forbidden for a non-Jew to learn Torah.  The Torah is betrothed to us and not to them.  One does not learn Gemara for an intellectual experience – which is their interest – but out of Yirat Shamayim – fear of Heaven (Chagigah 13a).  

 

Reform and Conservative Conversions

Q: Are Reform and Conservative conversions valid?

A: Certainly not.  An essential element of the conversion is accepting the yoke of the Mitzvot, and this is lacking.  Shut Achiezer 3:26.  Shut Igrot Moshe, Yoreh Deah 2:128, Even Ha-Ezer 3:3.  Shut Shevet Ha-Levi 10:224.  Shut Mishneh Halachot 12:193.

 

Matrilineal Descent

Q: Where is it written in the Torah that Judaism follows matrilineal descent?

A: Devarim 7:3-4.  Kiddushin 68b.

Q: I heard that some say that it was a later decree?

A: Nonsense.  It is explicitly mentioned in Ezra 7:3-4, and he did not invent it.

 

Staring at Women

Q: Is it forbidden for men to stare at women, or do women also have to be careful that men not stare at them?

A: Both.  "A woman needs to be modest and careful that men not stare at her, aside from her husband".  Rabbenu Yonah, Igeret Ha-Teshuvah 159.

 

Coca Cola

Q: Is Coca Cola Kosher in all countries?

A: Not necessarily.  There are many ingredients.  It requires certification (See the amazing Teshuvah regarding the Kashrut of Coca Cola in Shut Karnei Ha-Hod, end of Volume 2, of Ha-Rav Tuvia Gefen, who served as Rabbi in Atlanta, where Coke is produced in America.  He discusses the secret ingredient in Coke).

Q: Is it true that Coca Cola is unhealthy?

A: This is a medical question.  All soft drinks cause damage on account of the sugar.  And some claim that Coke causes damage on account of the phosphoric acid which causes continuing damage to one's kidneys.

 

Bill with Tchernichovski

Q: Is it appropriate for the State of Israel to put out a bill with the face of the poet Shaul Tchernichovski, who was married to a non-Jew?

A: It is not appropriate.

 

Tzedakah to a Criminal

Q: A person evaded taxes and is now having a trial which could end up in jail-time.  Is it possible to give him Tzedakah for an expensive attorney who could save him?

A: This has nothing to do with Tzedakah.  But it is a kindness.  Kindness is according to the need and ability.  But it seems that there are other persons who are more in need of a kindness (Ha-Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach was once asked regarding a Jew who stole a significant amount of money and was serving a jail sentence in America.  Is it proper to collect large sums of money to help free him because of the Mitzvah of Pidyon Shevuyim – Redeeming Captives?  Ha-Rav Shlomo Zalman said: "Pidyom Shevuyim?!  What does this have to do with Pidyon Shevuyim?  Pidyom Shevuyim is when non-Jews kidnap a Jew for no reason, and put him in jail.  According to my understanding, they don't kidnap Jews in America in order to extort money.  After all, the Torah says 'Do not steal', and he stole.  On the contrary, it is good for him to sit in jail a little and learn that it is forbidden to steal."  Ha-Rav Shlomo Zalman added that if they wanted to collect money for his wife and children, however, it would obviously be a Mitzvah.  Ve-alehu Lo Yibol Volume 2, pp. 113-114). 

Who Should be Part of the Body that Selects the Chief Rabbi?


[Be-Ahavah U-Be-Emunah – Bemidbar 5773 – translated by R. Blumberg]

 

When Maran Ha-Rav Avraham Yitzchak Kook founded the Chief Rabbinate almost everyone – religious and secular - was in favor. Even the secular understood that having a country includes having religion, and that it was important for there to be a Chief Rabbi for both internal and external purposes. There were only a handful of religious Jews who did not want there to be a Chief Rabbi. People quote Ha-Rav Chaim Zonnenfeld, the head of the opposition, as having said, “At first he will be a traditional Orthodox Rabbi, then he will be a Rabbi-Doctor, and after that he will be a reform Rabbi.” It was this he feared, and indeed, Rav Kook and the rest of the Rabbis feared this too.

It all depends on who picks the Chief Rabbi.

The Rabbis said that the ones who would chose the Chief Rabbi should, themselves, be Rabbis. The secular public refused, however, and said that the decision should be a public one. Ostensibly the Rabbis were right. I have pointed out with regards to Bezalel, the architect of the Mishkan, the Desert Tabernacle, that holiness takes precedence over wisdom, and wisdom takes precedence over the public’s opinion. Yet the secular said that throughout the generations it was the community that chose the Rabbi, and that was what should happen now as well. The Rabbis responded that there can be no comparison. At one time, the public had all been G-d-fearing, whereas now, in Eretz Yisrael, there was nothing like that. Why were they choosing a Rabbi? What did they need a Rabbi for? As stated at the start, the Mara De-Atra, Rabbinic head of the community, is the one we trust and whose word we obey, yet the secular have no intention of obeying him anyway. If so, why should they have a say in deciding? As stated, they were in favor of having a Chief Rabbi, but not in order to obey him, but to meet political needs.

In the end, a committee was set up, with the British, the Rabbis and the Jewish People equally represented. That committee in turn decided that the make-up of the voting body should be two-thirds Rabbis and one third representatives of the communities. Two-thirds of Rabbis makes a majority, and some of the communal representatives were G-d-fearing people as well. With this decision, all doubts that could have arisen were quashed, and the Rabbis prevailed.

It should further be stressed that secular individuals who choose a Chief Rabbi do not want him in order to heed his halachic rulings. They want a Chief Rabbi who will heed what they say. We can understand this desire, but that is not what a Rabbi does. That is what Ha-Rav Yosef Dov Soloveitchik called “the new idolatry, idolatry to public opinion” (Divrei Ha-Rav, p. 52). In that system, public opinion determines what you must think and what you must do. You are enslaved to public opinion.

Yet, as Socrates said, public opinion can be wrong. There is no need to have learned in yeshiva to understand this. You need intelligence, just as Socrates had.  What he said, however, did not curry favor with public opinion, and he therefore was sentenced to death. He was given three options: exile, silence or execution. He said, “If I am unable to say what I think, or if I go into exile and can no longer have an influence, my life is no life.” He drank poison, continued speaking, fell asleep and died. His point was: public opinion should not be the deciding factor in moral/philosophical matters.

It is certainly forbidden for public opinion to take precedence in the selection of a Chief Rabbi. It is a tertiary factor that should come only after the primary factor, which is holiness, and the secondary factor, which is wisdom, as Rav Kook explained (Ein Aya, Berachot, Chapter 9, Letter 28).

Indeed, first and foremost comes holiness. Ha-Gaon Ha-Rav Avraham Shapira, ztz"l, related that one time there was uncertainty over who should be the Chief Rabbi - Rav Herzog or Rav Charlap. In the end, Rav Herzog was chosen. Rav Shapira said, “It was a shame, because Rav Charlop was on a supreme level of holiness.” He immediately added, “Rav Herzog was holy too, but Rav Charlop was more so.” Rav Shapira grieved over what occurred.  We look back nostalgically to a time when the choice was between Rav Herzog and Rav Charlop. In the end, because Rav Herzog had been the Chief Rabbi of Ireland and was more accustomed to the Rabbinate, he was chosen. That is the sort of selection process that there needs to be.

First you need a holy man.

Naso: A Happy Marriage


[Tal Chermon]


Parashat Naso teaches us that we must do everything possible to ensure good marital relations - even to the point of actually “blotting out” G-d’s name. One reason for this may be that the Torah places marital relations within the context of loving one’s fellow man. This Mitzvah is not only a lofty ideal to be carried out in principle, it is also an obligation to treat those around us with love every day. “Love of Klal Israel” begins with a general love of Judaism and Jews, but must also be expressed in simple acts of love for real people.

This is obviously a difficult task. It is not easy to rise to the level of those great Tzadikkim who loved every member of Am Israel with all their hearts and souls. Where does one start? At the very least, we should love one member of Am Israel with all our heart. And who should that on person be? Our husband or wife. The Gemarra teaches us that the main criterion for choosing a mate should be whether we feel we can love him or her "as yourself” (Kiddushin 41a).

Once you succeed in truly loving one other person on a day-to-day basis, you have built yourself the foundation for establishing a loving relationship with everyone else. “Love your neighbor” reaches its peak when you really love your mate, despite the inevitable tensions that arise in every marriage. It’s quite easy to love a Jew living in Japan without making any compromises; loving someone you have to live with is much more difficult. There are differences of opinion, and accidental - or purposeful - slights. One gets upset or angry at the other. This may even be what the Torah means by prohibiting hatred “in our hearts.” “Hate” need not be an emotion so extreme that it leads to murder or violence; it may also be simply bearing a grudge.

But it is not only the most extreme hatred that is forbidden: even a tiny crumb cannot be tolerated - just as a tiny portion of ham is just as unkosher as a large plateful. If one mate bears a grudge against the other on account of some unkind words or action, it is considered “hatred”. The Torah teaches us that in such a case one must either speak softly but firmly and ask the other why he did such a thing, or alternatively, completely forgive and forget the incident. It is absolutely forbidden to bear a grudge (Rambam, Hilchot De’ot 6:6).

Such incidents may happen every day, but it is not practical to discuss each and every one of them. If we did, it might vey well be even more harmful than the little hurts which provoked the discussions. As Shakespeare put it, it causes a “tempest in a teapot.” A more practical solution is to agree to simply erase such minor infractions from one’s mind.

Man suffers enough from society around him. We all live within a social context from which we both benefit and suffer. Some people are so sensitive that they suffer immensely. And some people are themselves to blame for the insults they suffer, because of their own failings. In any case, by the end of the day, we are all weary from the wear and tear of our social interactions. We need a sanctuary where we are accepted unconditionally, without having to answer for our failings or to make up for them. This is not, of course, the be-all and end-all of the institution of marriage, but it is one of its important components. A mate who accepts you and loves you as you are, instead of throwing all the books at you, provides an immeasurable amount of strength and support.

This is not to say that one should completely ignore all the other’s failings or confuse good with evil. Amends must certainly be made. But this only comes after the establishment of unconditional love, based on the secret of mutual “blotting out.” Only after that, can we begin to correct the wrongs.

Why should you be dissatisfied with your mate, or bear him a grudge? Are you yourself perfect? Isn’t it better to ‘make a deal’ that you will both ‘forgive and forget?’ Our sages declared: “He who forgives others has all his own sins forgiven.” If you forgive your friends even when they don’t deserve it, you will be treated the same way by the Heavenly Tribunal.

It is well known that Yom Kippur does not atone for sins committed against one’s fellow man, unless that person has agreed to forgive (see end of Mishna Yoma). This is the message of the Tefilla Zaka said before Kol Nidrei. Of course, there is no need to wait until Yom Kippur. The Ari Ha-Kadosh composed a prayer to be recited every night before retiring: “I forgive every person who has sinned against me, whether accidentally or on purpose....” There were other rabbis, including Rav Kook, who even added, “I forgive those who will sin against me in the future.”

 This is the kind of relationship one should have with his spouse - complete readiness to forgive and forget, even in advance. Such an attitude promotes consideration, friendship, and happiness.


There is a famous story about the Ba’al Shem Tov and his disciples: They once asked him whom to emulate in preparation for the High Holidays. He suggested observing one particular man’s behavior, and they saw an amazing scene: The man stood before his fireside holding two notebooks and said, “King of the World! In this notebook I have written down all the sins I have committed. Unfortunately, they are very numerous. I confess. In the second notebook I have written down all my sufferings - and You, King of the World, allowed them. I “forgive” You for all the troubles You caused me, and I ask You to please forgive me for all my sins. See, I am throwing both notebooks into the fire.”


Husband and wife must also learn to throw both notebooks into the fire. Sometimes we may think: Fine, I can forgive all the hurts I suffered myself, but not the sins committed against Heaven. They are what make me angry. To this we must reply: Don’t worry about God, and don’t hate your husband or wife in His Name! In Parashat Naso, we learn that God commands that His Ineffable Name be blotted out in the bitter waters in order to make peace between husband and wife. No human is completely free of violence, be it verbal or physical; this is one of the most difficult tendencies to overcome. It may sometimes appear disguised as righteousness, or in the guise of admonishments and lectures on morality (see Rav Kook, “Midot Re’eya, on Tochacha), or even in a mildly antagonistic silence. Difficult as it may be to completely overcome this tendency, we should at least try to leave G-d out of it. “God is good to all, and His Mercy extends to all of His creatures” (Tehillim 145:9). He is willing for His Name to be blotted out in order to restore marital bliss.

                     
We always advise young couples: First of all, learn to live together, only afterwards, try to attain Kedusha (a high spiritual level). Simple natural married love takes priority. A couple who aspires to build a life of holiness which is not based on simple honest love will end up with a dishonest relationship. The first step is to stop all mutual “point giving,” and throw all the lists in the fire, even if they involve matters of Heaven. There is no better way to express this philosophy – that complete, mutual, unlimited forgiveness, even regarding religious observance, must form the basis for marital harmony - than in our sages’ concise comment on our Parashah: “The Ineffable Name is blotted out for the sake of making peace between a husband and wife.”

Shut SMS #207


Learning on the Night of Shavuot

Q: Is there an obligation to learn the entire night of Shavuot?

A: No.  But it is a proper custom.  Someone who is unable should try to learn until midnight (Magen Avraham, Orach Chaim 494).

Q: Which is preferable – learning all night and falling asleep during Shacharit or going to sleep?

A: Going to sleep.  Davening Shacharit without falling asleep is a basic halachah, and learning all night is a worthwhile addition. 

Q: Which is preferable – learning during the night, or learning during the day, if I will learn more during the day?

A: During the day, since learning more Torah is a basic halachah, and learning Torah all night on Shavuot is a worthwhile addition (This is unlike the ruling of Ha-Rav Chaim Kanvieski that the custom is to learn all night, and it is preferable to learn during the night even if one learns less than he would have during the day.  Piskei Shemuot, pp. 81-82.  Although Ha-Rav Yitzchak Zev Soloveitchik, the Brisker Rav, was surprised that people are so particular to stay awake the entire night of Shavuot, which is a custom, while on Pesach night, where there is a law to discuss the Exodus from Egypt until one is overcome by sleep, people are not so careful.  And in the city of Brisk, people were not careful to follow the custom of staying awake the entire night of Shavuot, since why is this night different from all other night?  And also, learning on Shavuot night is not more important than learning during the day. Uvdot Ve-Hanhagot Le-Beit Brisk vol. 2, p. 79).

Q: I heard that it is forbidden to engage in idle chatter on the night of Shavuot?

A: It is not a prohibition, but it is proper, and one should try as much as possible to refrain (Kaf Ha-Chaim 494:11).

Q: Is one obligated to learn the Tikun Leil Shavuot?

A: No.  A person should learn Torah in a subject that his heart desires (Avodah Zarah 19a.  And Ha-Rav Chaim Kanievski said that there are different customs, each of which is acceptable.  Piskei Shemuot, p. 81).

Q: If one's father says the Tikun, should his son also say the Tikun, or is it permissible to learn Gemara?

A: It is a personal decision (Ha-Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv said: "It is better for him to learn Massechet Baba Metzia, Perek Ha-Socher Et Ha-Po'alim [One who hires workers], and even if his father says the Tikun."  And Ha-Rav Chaim Kanievski said: "If his father says the Tikun, he should also say the Tikun".  Yadoon Moshe vol. 9 #59).

Q: Do women also need to learn all night?

A: They are not obligated, but it is certainly a good thing.

 

Milchigs

Q: Is there an obligation to eat Milchigs on Shavuot?

A: It is the Custom.  Yemenite Jews do not do so (Shulchan Aruch Ha-Mekutzar, p. 72).

Q: Does one have to eat an entire Milchig meal?

A: It is enough to have one dairy food.  And it is then possible to wash out one's mouth, wash one's hands and clean the table, and have a Fleischig meal (Or Le-Tzion 3:196.  And the Steipler Gaon would only have a Milchig meal at night.  Orchot Rabbenu vol. 1, p. 98).

 

Early Davening on Shavuot

Q: Can one daven Maariv early on Shavuot, or is it a problem because one needs 7 complete weeks of Sefirat Ha-Omer?
A: Ashkenazim – No, Sefardim are lenient (Mishneh Berurah 414:1.  Shut Yechaveh Daat 6:30).

Laws of Staying Awake All Night on Shavuot


[Shut She'eilat Shlomo 1:26-27, 222 and Q&A from radio call-in show]

 

The custom of learning Torah the entire night of Shavuot is mentioned by the Magen Avraham (Orach Chaim #494), based on the Zohar: we dedicate the night to learning Torah in an attempt to rectify a mistake made by the Nation of Israel at the time of the Giving of the Torah.  When Hashem “arrived” to give the Torah to the Nation of Israel, we were still sleeping and had to be woken up.  The custom therefore developed to stay awake all night to spirituality make-up for our oversleeping and to show our zeal for the Torah.  But one should be aware that if, on account of the exhaustion of learning Torah all night, he cannot daven Shacharit in the morning with proper concentration, it is better not to stay up since davening properly is a clear obligation (the Magen Avraham makes this exact point regarding staying up all night on Yom Kippur – see Orach Chaim 611:11).

In fact, Ha-Rav Yitzchak Zev Soloveitchik, the Brisker Rav, was surprised that people are so particular to stay awake the entire night of Shavuot, which is a custom, while on Pesach night, when there is a law to discuss the Exodus from Egypt until one is overcome by sleep, people are not so careful.  And in the city of Brisk, people were not careful to follow the custom of staying awake the entire night of Shavuot, since why is this night different from all other night...?  And also, learning on Shavuot night is not more important than learning during the day… (Uvdot Ve-Hanhagot Le-Beit Brisk vol. 2, p. 79).

And it is related in the book "Ha-Shakdan" (vol. 2, p. 240) that one of Ha-Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv's grandsons once asked him why he does not stay awake all night on Shavuot like everyone else, but follows his regular learning schedule of waking up at 2:00 AM to learn Torah. Rav Elyashiv explained that he calculated that if he changed his few hours of sleep on that night, he would not gain more time learning Torah - he would actually lose 15 minutes of learning!  For a few precious minutes of learning Torah, he decided that it is preferable to go to sleep at the beginning of the night as usual.

Each person should therefore carefully consider if it is worthwhile for him to stay up all night since there is a concern that "his gain is offset by his loss."

 

For one who remains awake all night, this is how he should act in the morning:

1.    Talit

One who wears Tzitzit all night should not recite a new blessing on it in the morning.  One should try to hear the blessing said by someone who is obligated to recite it or have the Tzitzit in mind when he recites the blessing over his Talit (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 8:16 with Mishnah Berurah #42).

 

2.    Netilat Yadayim

One should wash "Netilat Yadayim" without a blessing or hear it from someone who is obligated to recite it (Shulchan Aruch Ha-Rav 4:13).  It is preferable to use the restroom as one is then obligated according to all opinions to wash "Netilat Yadayim."  After washing "Netilat Yadayim," he should recite the blessing of "Al Netilat Yadayim" and "Asher Yatzar" (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 4:13 with Mishnah Berurah #27, 29, 30).

 

3.    "Elohai Neshamah" and "Ha-Ma'avir Sheinah"

They should be recited without the ending of using Hashem's Name or be heard from someone who is obligated to recite them, since these blessings where established over the return of the soul and removal of sleep and neither of these occurred (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 47 with Mishnah Berurah #30 and Biur Halachah).  If one sleeps a half an hour, one is obligated to recite these blessings (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 4:16 with Mishnah Berurah #34-35 and Biur Halachah).

 

4.    "Ha-Noten Le-Yaef Koach"

One should recite this blessing even if he is very tired, since this blessing was not established for the person's individual state, but as a general praise of Hashem who created His world which includes the removal of tiredness (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 46 with Mishnah Berurah #22 and Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 47 with Mishnah Berurah #28).  Chasidim recite all of the morning blessings even if they remain awake all night (Shulchan Aruch Ha-Rav 47:7 and Siddur Chabad in the laws before the morning blessings and blessings over learning Torah).

 

5.    Blessings over Learning Torah

There is a dispute whether these blessings should be recited if one remains awake all night.  One option is that the morning before Shavuot, one make a condition that the blessings will be for the following day as well.  One can also hear the blessings from someone who did sleep, with both individuals having in mind that the blessings will apply to both of them (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 47 with Mishnah Berurah #25-28).  If neither of these is an option, one can recite the blessings based on the opinion of the Shut Sha'agat Aryeh (#24-25) that these blessings are a Torah Mitzvah and in the case of a doubt, one is strict to recite them.  This ruling is found in Maran Ha-Rav Kook's commentary on the siddur "Olat Re'eiyah" (vol. 1, p. 59 #5) and in Ha-Rav Ovadiah Yosef's responsa (Shut Yabia Omer vol. 5, Orach Chaim #6 and Shut Yechaveh Daat 3:33).

In this regard, women are also required to recite the blessings over learning Torah and these blessings are printed in all of the Siddurim for women.  But how can they recite the blessing "Blessed is Hashem…who has made us holy and commanded us to engage in words of Torah" when they are not obligated to learn Torah?  There are various answers, but the answer of Ha-Rav Yitzchak Zev Soloveitchik, known as the Griz, on the Rambam (at the end of Hilchot Berachot, p. 10) and Maran Ha-Rav Kook (Orach Mishpat 11, 2) is that these are not blessings over performing a mitzvah but blessings of praise.  If the Torah was not given, the world would be in darkness for both men and women.  Women therefore also thank Hashem for the Torah being in the world. 

 

Ha-Rav Moshe Levinger, Great and Heroic


[Be-Ahavah U-Be-Emunah – Behar-Bechukotai 5773 – translated by R. Blumberg]

 

Our master and teacher, Ha-Rav Ha-Gaon Rabbi Moshe Levinger shelita, is certainly worthy of the Moskowitz Prize for Zionism, and he is worthy of a lot more than that. One time Ha-Gaon Ha-Rav Shlomo Min Hahar, zt”l said, “It should only be that I should have a place in Paradise by his side, because of all that he did for the sake of Eretz Yisrael.” And we pray that he should live for many more years in the earthly paradise of Eretz Yisrael.

Yet make no mistake: Before Rav Levinger is a man of Eretz Yisrael, he is a man of Torah, or, more precisely, he is a man of Torah and a man of Eretz Yisrael – Eretz Yisrael deriving from the Torah. Indeed, he once actually initiated the creation of a political party which he called “The Torah and the Land”. He is great in Torah, and a hero regarding Eretz Yisrael. That same description, “great and heroic”, originated with Maran Ha-Rav Avraham Yitzchak Ha-Cohain Kook (Ma'amarei Ha-Re'eiyah 127). Rav Kook explained that there are a lot of men who are great in Torah and great in holiness, but they are not heroes. In other words, when they encounter difficulties, they back off. Rav Kook wrote that Rav Shmuel Mohliver was both great and heroic, and although he suffered battles and outright wars, suffering and

insult, he held firm to his path with heroism and courage, and never backed off.

Ha-Gaon Ha-Rav Levinger is a true “Gaon”, a true genius, in Torah. I met him for the first time when he established the Hebron settlers' group in 5728. He was only thirty-three years old, and already he was a great Gaon in Torah, a true genius, a genius in acumen and a genius in breadth of knowledge, a genius in sterling character and a genius in the fear of G-d, a genius in modesty and a genius in humility.

And indeed, one time “Reb Avrum”, Ha-Gaon Ha-Rav Avraham Shapira, zt”l, pointed out to me, on a humorous note, many years after, “Don't refer to him as 'our master and teacher'. When you learned Torah from him, you were young, and now you are both young...'

So I follow his wish, even though being a minor disciple of a great man leaves a great imprint on one's soul. Indeed, already then Rav Levinger was a genius, and I am not the only one who noticed that. All the true scholars in Yeshivat Mitnachlei Chevron noticed it as well. Due to his struggles over Eretz Yisrael, the media hid this primary side of his personality. Another sin of the media was that they presented him as an aggressive, angry person. Certainly in matters of principle he is firm in his views, and so must every true Torah scholar be, especially if he is not just great but also heroic. Yet anyone who knows him even slightly, knows just how gentle, humble, accommodating and smiling he is. What a marvelous smile he has! It is a sweet smile, a wise smile. Anyone in Rav Levinger's proximity will fall in love with him. He will fall in love with him, but will feel the greatest reverence for him.

Yet he is not only great. He is also heroic. He is not like those leaders who send others into battle while they remain in their easy chair. No! With any struggle that he viewed as just, he went first, and he proclaimed, “After me!” and his entire personality cried out, like Gidon, “See what I do, and do the same” (Shoftim 7:17). He did not send out innocent lads on missions causing them to be arrested and sit in prison. Rather, he himself set out on the missions, and he himself sat in prison. Obviously, I am not presenting sitting in prison as an ideal! I am just providing examples of the true heroism of his personality. He is not just a hero in words, not just a hero as far as telling others what to do, but a hero himself.

For what did he sit in prison? Not for shady money dealings or deception. Rav Moshe Levinger is as straight as a ruler. Rather, it is because he defended the strength and glory of the Nation, and he still does so and shall continue doing so. He was on trial more than ten times, had costly fines leveled against him, was convicted and sentenced to prison, sometimes resulting in actual prison time and sometimes in suspended sentences, because he defended the strength and glory of the Jewish people, because he shot at those who attacked him with rocks. Sometimes he forced Arab merchants who had behaved provocatively towards Jews to close their stores, and similarly, he responded forcefully when an Arab insulted his son in the street. One time, after he was freed from prison, he proclaimed, “I will continue in my path.” Once more let me say that here is not the place to discuss whether his path is the desirable one or not.

One time he said to me, “Reb Shlomo” (that’s what he humbly called me), “One doesn’t always need peace and quiet like you think,” by which he meant: Sometimes you have to show what a hero is. One time when we were at Yamit, struggling against the destruction, he called for an appalling initiative: That Torah scholars should lock themselves in a room and threaten collective suicide if Yamit was handed over to the enemy. His halachic reasoning was as follows: For Eretz Yisrael, every sort of self-sacrifice is required. The initiative did not get off the ground, due to a lack of volunteers

He suggested it to me as well, saying, “Reb Shlomo, this involves a weighty decision, for you and for your family. Think well.” I humbly disagreed with him, but nobody could dare to claim that he lacked self-sacrifice!

Yet he didn’t just possess self-sacrifice of this sort, but, first and foremost, self-sacrifice for building and for positive activities. He was a partner in the renewal of Gush Etzion after the Six Day War, and afterwards, with great toil and stubborn effort, he established the Hebron settlers’ group, out of which sprang forth all the settlements of Judea and Samaria. One cannot imagine how great a deed this was.

Time will tell, and people will come to understand. Once, in 5747, the newspaper Hadashot asked: “From amongst twenty-two Israeli personages representing the entire public spectrum, who has had the greatest influence on Israeli society during the past twenty years?” First place went to Menachem Begin together with Rav Moshe Levinger….

Let us go back to our starting point: Torah and the Land, and from the Torah, the Land. Rav Levinger does not belong to the practical, pragmatic stream within Gush Emunim, or to the leadership of Judea and Samaria, but rather to the ideological, moral, spiritual and Torah-oriented stream. For over forty-five years he has been teaching that the more spiritually things are run, the more they will succeed.

He is a man of morality and justice - quite the opposite of how the media distortedly presents him.

The State of Israel, he says, is not just a military and economic dream, but, first and foremost, a moral, spiritual, social dream, as appears in the words of the Prophets.

Every settlement built in the Land of Israel has spiritual/ethical worth. G-d said of Avraham, “I have given him special attention so that he will command his children and his household after him, and they will keep G-d's way, doing charity and justice” (Bereshit 18:19).  Loving your fellow Jew, loving social justice, loving hard work. First, explains Rav Levinger, it was necessary to fly a national flag over the settlements. Now, we must raise up over that flag a noble, spiritual banner, a banner that is great and exalted. Give greatness to our G-d!

Rav Levinger’s vitality has not left him. He learns Torah and teaches Torah, lifts people’s spirits and gives new life to the dejected. He is yet young, and will yet accomplish much. He is great and heroic, brilliant in Torah and a fighter for the Land. He has no need of the Zionism Award. Zionism needs the prize of his contribution. All the settlers of Judea and Samaria are his prize.

He is not a person looking for acclaim. Far from it. He is not a person seeking to appear attractive to the media. He is a person who raises a banner, a banner of the truth, a banner of the Torah.

Everything I have written here applies equally to his wife, Rabbanit Miriam, who is together with him in all his holy work.

 

Shut SMS #206




Ha-Rav answers hundreds of text message questions a day!  Here's a sample:

Failing to Pay Shul Dues

Q: If someone refuses to pay Shul dues, is it permissible for the board to not to give him an Aliyah or allow him to be a Shliach Tzibur when he is a mourner?

A: Yes.  A Shul is maintained by its board, which establishes the rules.  If the person does not agree with these rules, he should go to a different Shul.  And if it is on account of a lack of money that he has not paid, he should request an exemption or discount.  See Rama, Orach Chaim 153:16 (Shut Tzitz Eliezer 2:22).

 

Visiting Two Graves

Q: When I visit my father's grave, is it permissible for me to visit other graves as well?

A: Some are strict to refrain from doing so.  Pnei Baruch 37:3.  But is it permissible according to the basic Halachah.

 

Inviting a Shabbat Desecrator

Q: Is it permissible to invite someone to a Shabbat meal to bring them closer to Torah if he will drive to get there?

A: No, on account of the prohibition of strengthening those who transgress (Shut Igrot Moshe, Orach Chaim 1:98-99.  Ha-Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv in Kav Naki #87.  Shut She'eilat Shlomo 4:109.  Ha-Rav Yosef Soloveitchik was once asked by a Rabbi: The most serious question I face in my Rabbinate is the question of inviting my congregants, who do not observe Shabbat, to eat at my home since I feel that I can have a big influence on them, but I know that they will drive to my house.  Ha-Rav Soloveitchik responded immediately: "What question it there about this, it is forbidden, and there is nothing to talk about".  Divrei Ha-Rav, p. 170).

 

Food from another Kosher Certification

Q: If I am a guest at someone's home and am served food from a Kosher certification that I refrain from eating, is it permissible for me to eat it?

A: Yes.  All Kosher certification is acceptable until proven otherwise.  Piskei Teshuvot 170:8 (and this is how Ha-Rav Yosef Chaim Zonnenfeld and Ha-Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach acted when they attended a Simchah.  They would eat food which they were strict about in their own homes, as it says in Tehillim 101:2: "I will walk with the simplicity of my heart within my house", i.e. In my simplicity, I will be strict within the confines of my home, but not when I am with others.  Ve-Alehu Lo Yibol Volume 2, p. 66).

 

Bar Mitzvah in the Middle of Sefirat Ha-Omer

Q: If a young man has a Bar Mitzvah in the middle of Sefirat Ha-Omer, can he continue counting Sefirat Ha-Omer with a blessing?

A: Ashekenazim – yes.  Shut Har Tzvi Orach Chaim #72.  Halichot Shlomo, p. 358.  Ha-Rav Yosef Shlomo Elyashiv in Ashrei Ha-Ish, p. 423 (and Shut Teshuvot Ve-Hanhagot 1:313.  Ha-Rav Yitzchak Hutner and Ha-Rav Yaakov Kamenetzky.  Shut Divrei Chachamim, p. 150).  Sefardim – from the outset, he should count without a blessing, but if he counts with a blessing, he has on whom to rely.  Chazon Ovadiah – Yom Tov, p. 221 (and see Shut Yechaveh Daat 3:29).

 

Converting in the Middle of Sefirat Ha-Omer

Q: If someone converts in the middle of Sefirat Ha-Omer, can he count from now on with a blessing?

A: Without a blessing.  He is missing days.  Birkei Yosef 493:20.

 

Ashkenazic Woman Counting Sefirah

Q: Can an Ashkenazic woman count Sefirah?

A: Some say she is obligated.  Magen Avraham.  Some say that she may do so.  Ha-Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv in Ashrei Ha-Ish, p. 427.  And others say that she may do so without a blessing.  Mishnah Berurah 493:3 (The Steipler Gaon would remind the women and girls in his house to count.  Orchot Rabbenu Volume 2, p. 94.  And Ha-Rav Moshe Feinstein said that the custom of their women is not to count, but they may do so with a blessing.  He explains that perhaps since the custom is not to count, some say that they should not recite a blessing, but they may do so based on the principle of "One who is not commanded and performs the Mitzvah".  Mesoret Moshe, p. 156). 

 

Sefardic Woman Counting Sefirah

Q: Can a Sefardic woman count Sefirah?

A: Some say that she should not count.  And others say that she may count without a blessing.  Kaf Ha-Chaim 493:9.  Chazon Ovadiah – Yom Tov, p. 220.

 

Yemenite Woman counting Sefirah

Q: Can a Yementie woman count Sefirah?

A: No.  Shulchan Aruch Ha-Mekutzar 67.