Ha-Rav Aharon Yehudah Leib Shteinman ztz"l: The Great and Normal Gaon

In the year 5674, the world shook and the great soul of Ha-Rav Aharon Yehudah Leib Shteinman ztz"l, Gaon, Tzadik, Lamdan and ascetic, entered the world.  In addition to these traits, he had yet another rare and cherished quality: normalcy.  There is a small group of Gedolei Yisrael who stand firm against all of the winds which try to move them rightward and leftward.  They are strong and steadfast, they do not compromise nor do they go to extremes.  Rather, they are moderate.  A Gadol such as this receives the rare blessing of ZN"L - May the memory of the NORMAL be remembered for the blessing.
This was Rav Shteinman, who ascended on high at the amazing age of 104.
Through his rulings and teachings, one sees over and over again how Rav Shteinman was a normal leader and Posek, and a person guided by common sense.  The great Poskim explain that when one is asked a question, he must first use his intellect.  The Torah was not given to the stupid but rather to the wise.  If he cannot answer the question through his intellect, then he uses the Torah, which is beyond intellect (Shut Chavatzelet Ha-Sharon 2:28.  Shut Minchat Yitzchat 9:150).
This was Rav Shteinman in all areas.
He expressed surprise that people travel great distances to receive a blessing from a Rabbi instead of running to Shul to receive Birkat Cohanim, a blessing from Hashem (Be-Orchotecha Lamdeni p. 38). 
It once happened that a Yeshiva student, who for a few years did not merit having children, asked Rav Shteinman: Is it worthwhile to move, since changing one's place can change one's luck?   Rav Shteinman responded harshly: There is no such thing!  Is the apartment guilty that you have not merited having children!?  There is no reason to move (Segulot Raboteinu pp. 121-122.  And see Rambam, Hilchot Teshuvah 2:4).
When the three teens were kidnapped in Israel, and the security forces assumed that they were located in the area of Hevron, one Rav used the Goral Ha-Gra (literally, the lottery of the Vilna Gaon - a method of opening the Tanach, and locating verses which answer particular questions), and the result was the verse: "And when he came to Lechim the Philistines shouted against him, and the Spirit of Hashem came mightily upon him" (Shoftim 15:14).  This Rav explained that the Philistines captured Shimshon, and bound his hands, and he succeeded to remove the ropes, and this hinted that the teens would be released.  Furthermore, he claimed that we learn from this verse where the teens are located, in the area of Hevron, since those who understand say that Lechi is in the area of Hevron.  In response, someone approached Ha-Rav Chaim Kanievski and suggested the Goral Ha-Gra to answer the question of the location of the three teens.  He said: "For this, one needs Ruach Ha-Kodesh, go to the Rosh Ha-Yeshiva", i.e. Ha-Rav Shteinman.  When they turned to him, he said: "Do I have Ruach Ha-Kodesh"?!  And he added: "If so, why are there Agunot?!  They should use the Goral Ha-Gra…".
And from where did Rav Shteinman receive his moderation and normalcy?
His parents were residents of the city of Brisk, neighbors of Ha-Rav Mi-Brisk, Ha-Griz Soloveitchik.  His father served as a teacher, Shamash of the Shul and supervisor of the Eruv.  There was an Eruv in the city of Brisk and the entire community carried on Shabbat but the Rav of the city, Ha-Rav Chaim Soloveitchik, the father of Ha-Griz, and the Dayan, Ha-Rav Simchah Zelig, were strict not to carry (Shut Mishneh Halachot 15:130).  And when Ha-Rav Yosef Soloveitchik visited Brisk in his youth, he went to check the Eruv on Erev Shabbat with Ha-Rav Simchah Zelig (Nefesh Ha-Rav p. 170).  While the Rabbis where strict not to carry, they did not force it upon the community, and ensured a way for them to carry.  One can see the traditions that Rav Shteinman received from Torat Brisk in the book "A'aleh Be-Tamar - Brisk".
Rav Shteinman was educated in Brisk and was known as a prodigy.  At the age of 20, he began to learn with great intensity, and continued in this way for the last 80 years.  When he received a draft notice from the Polish army, he immigrated to Switzerland, learned in Yeshiva there and became a Ra"m in the Yeshiva.  During the Second World War, he was taken to a work camp and forced to pave roads.  Following an illness, he was released and was able to make Aliyah with his wife.  He then learned in a Yeshiva in Petach Tikvah.  Rav Shteinman became very close with the Chazon Ish.  The traditions that he received from him may be seen in the book "A'aleh Be-Tamar – Chazon Ish".
Rav Shteinman stood firmly and with moderation on these two pillars, Ha-Rav Mi-Brisk and the Chazon Ish.
At a cornerstone laying of a Yeshiva which was transplanted to Eretz Yisrael from Europe, Ha-Rav Yechezkel Avramsky praised the work of Ha-Rav Mi-Ponevitch, Ha-Rav Yosef Shlomo Kahaneman, who established the Ponevitch Yeshiva in Eretz Yisrael, and said that our Sages already stated: "In the future, the Shuls and Yeshiva of Babylonian will be established in Eretz Yisrael (Megillah 29a.  Pininim Mi-Shulchan Gevoha - Bereshit, p. 135.  And see at length regarding this saying in Shut Eretz Yisrael pp. 240-252).
Rav Shteinman was truly one of the foundations of the transfer of Torah from Europe to Eretz Yisrael.  He was appointed by Ha-Rav Mi-Ponevitch to head the Yeshiva Ketana of Ponevitch and its Kollel.
He established other Kollelim and with great self sacrifice delivered Shiurim in many different venues in Gemara, Halachah, Shulchan Aruch, Mishnah Berurah, Musar, the book Derech Hashem of the Ramchal and in the books Nefesh Ha-Chaim and Ruach Chaim of Reb Chaim of Volozhin.
His entire Torah learning was built upon his humility.
He published some 30 Sefarim including Ayelet Ha-Shachar on the Torah and on the Gemara, as well as many Sifrei Musar.

After the passing of Ha-Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv, Ha-Rav Shteinman was considered by most to be the supreme spiritual authority for the Litvishe Yeshiva world.  While Rav Elyashiv essentially dealt with Halachic rulings, Rav Shteinman dealt with every issue in the world.
He directed political parties, the Charedi educational system, Va'ad Ha-Yeshivot, Tzedakah organizations, Teshuvah organizations, Family Purity organizations, Badatz She'erit Yisrael and a newspaper.  He traveled outside of Israel various times in order to strengthen the communities there and raise money for Yeshivot and the different organizations.  He ruled that the newspaper should only wage war against opinions which were contrary to the Torah and not against individuals.  He was involved in every area of life.  It once happened that a young Rabbi, lacking in Torah knowledge, wanted to disagree with Rav Shteinman.  Based on of lack of knowledge, he could not disagree based on sources, so he claimed that Rav Shteinman was detached from reality, but he proved that he himself was the detached one…  
Regarding problems in the State of Israel, Rav Shteinman held that one should not wage war but established institutions to teach Torah and deal with Kiruv.
Regarding drafting Yeshiva students, he opposed the language of "Be killed and do not transgress" but expressed his view in a more gentle and normal manner, stating that they should not be disturbed from their Torah learning.  He also said that someone who is not learning Torah should serve in the army or learn a trade.  Only after a law was passed that if a specific number of students from the Ultra-Orthodox world did serve in the army, there would be criminal sanctions against one who refused to do so, did he say with great sorrow: this is a horrible Chilul Hashem of uprooting the Torah.  He sat and cried with intense pain that the State of Israel declared that learning Torah could be considered a crime.
Rav Shteinman also counseled people in matters of family life and education.  One can also see his normalcy in his attributing family and educational problems largely to people's arrogance.
Based on Reb Chaim of Volozhin (Igrot p. 102), Rav Shteinman said that one who does not agree to a Shidduch based on religious background violates the prohibition of being arrogant.  There was once a Shidduch with a young woman whose brothers went off the path.  The young man came to ask Rav Shteinman about this issue, since the Gemara in Baba Batra (110a) says that if one is interested in marrying a woman he should check her brothers, since children are similar to their mother's brothers.  Rav Shteinman said that this applies when people live in a small village, and thus in a closed environment.  If children go off the path there, it is on account of the parents.  But everything is open in our days.  The parents can provide a completely proper education and the child can still go off the path (see further in Re'im Ahuvim p. 183).  And he told men who were about to marry that a happy marriage is based on three things: giving in, giving in and giving in, since the root of all inter-personal problems is egoism, i.e. arrogance (Adnei Ha-Bayit, p. 149).  Furthermore, someone once came to him and asked if they are obligated to clean for Chametz in the cracks between the tiles on the floor.  He answered wisely: Yes, and since it is so severe a matter, don't rely on your wife, but rather check them yourself…
Regarding education, he instructed that one not learn secular studies, since the essence is fear of Hashem and learning Torah.  He taught that Yeshiva students should not be involved in politics and should refrain from luxuries.  He rejected punishing children, and expelling or not accepting weak students.  It once happened that there were parents who wanted to register their child to learn in a Talmud Torah, but the parents of current students did not want the child to be accepted because his parents were religious but not Frum.  The administrators asked Rav Shteinman if they should accept him, since he could negatively influence the other children.  He yelled that anyone who does not want to accept him suffers from arrogance!!  Arrogance!!  Arrogance!!  And he added that he learned in the Talmud Torah in Brisk with the sons of the Brisker Rav and all sorts of other children.  It happens in every Talmud Torah that there are children who go off the path.
During his entire life, Rav Shteinman worked on being humble and battled against being arrogant.  Therefore when extremists disparaged him, he was one of the Gedolei Yisrael who was "one who is disgraced and does not disgrace, he hears [others recounting] his shame and does not answer, he serves Hashem from love and happily accepts afflictions" (Shabbat 88b).  As we mentioned, under certain circumstances, Rav Shteinman did not oppose certain Charedim from serving in the Charedi units in Tzahal.  Extremists therefore graffitied on a wall: "Shteinman = Kook", comparing him to Maran Ha-Rav Kook.  Ha-Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv once walked past this graffiti and thought it was meant as a compliment and said: Ha-Rav Shteinman is certainly a great Gadol, but not on the same level as Ha-Rav Kook… (see our eulogy on Rav Elyashiv for his relationship with Maran Ha-Rav Kook).
Rav Shteinman was once told that some people were distributing fliers against him.  He said: If I knew who was doing this, I would need to pay him, since at my age I don't have the strength for ascetic practices and fasts…  The source for his words is found in the book "Sha'arei Kedushah" of Ha-Rav Chaim Vital that if a person knew how much insults help to atone for his sins, he would pursue them!
And above all, it is possible to see Rav Shteinman's normalcy and humility in his simplicity.  He was always frugal.  At his wedding, he only invited 15 guests since it was paid for by Tzedakah.  He also returned money that was given to him at his wedding.  He did not eat hot food or sweets, but rather simple food.  He lived in a two and a half room apartment that was never renovated.  He had simple beds, and his chairs were made from orange crates, lacking a place to rest your back.  Ha-Rav Elyashiv had an equally simple and sparse apartment.  Rav Shteinman would meet Gedolei Yisrael and leaders of the country in a little room.  Someone once said in the name of the Chazon Ish that a house such as this is not respectful.  It is a Chilul Hashem.  Rav Shteinman responded: On the contrary, the more it is beautiful, the more of a Chilul Hashem it is.
It is told that a wealthy businessman once visited the Chafetz Chaim.  He was astounded by the lack of furniture in the Chafetz Chaim’s home.  Unable to contain himself, he asked, “Where is your furniture"?  The Chafetz Chaim responded by asking him where was his furniture.  The man, a bit surprised by the question, explained that he was only passing through. The Chafetz Chaim said that in this world, he too, was only passing through.  
We merited an immense Torah scholar, who worked on remaining humble his entire life and fought against arrogance, in both the spiritual and physical realm.

May his soul be bound up with the bonds of the living with all of the Tzadikim and Geonim.

New English book from Ha-Rav Shlomo Aviner - 6th Book - Heroes of the Tanach

In these beautifully crafted discussions of our ancestors in the Tanach, Ha-Rav Aviner clearly elucidates the traits and potentials which we have received from each of our ancestors.  These heroes are not only the foundation of our Nation, but the foundation of each of us individually as well.  When we read about their experiences and their responses, we learn what is inherent within our national and personal soul.

Other books in series currently available:
1. Short and Sweet - Text Message Q&A - Volume 1 [Revised addition]
2. Prophecies for the Generations - Explorations into the Haftarot
3. Rabbenu - Ha-Rav Tzvi Yehudah Ha-Cohain Kook
4. With Love and Faith

Price per book: $25 or 80 NIS (shipping included)
To order: 02-628-4101 [in Israel] or toratravaviner@gmail.com

US President Who Did One Good Thing

Question: Isn't it true that although the President of the United States did one good thing when he recognized Yerushalayim as our capital, he has also done a great number of problematic things?
Answer: Our great Rabbi, the Rambam, writes: "Each and every person has merits and sins. A person whose merits exceed his sins is [deemed] righteous…This reckoning is not calculated on the basis of the number of merits and sins, but [takes into account] their magnitude.  There are some merits which outweigh many sins, as implied by: 'Because in him, there was found a good deed'" (Melachim 1 14:13.  Rambam, Hilchot Teshuvah 1:1-2).
And to whom does this verse refer? To King Avi'ah, son of Yeravam, about whom it is stated: "And all of Israel will eulogize him and bury him, for he alone of Yeravam will come to a grave, because in him, there was found a good deed toward Hashem, the G-d of Israel, in the House of Yeravam" (Melachim 1 14:13).
And what good deed did he do?  Some explain that he removed the guards placed by his father to prevent the Nation of Israel ascending to Yerushalayim on the holidays, and he himself ascend to Yerushalayim.  Others explain that he got rid of the orchards planted by his father to block the roads and thus prevent the Nation of Israel from ascending to Yerushalayim (Mo'ed Katan 28b.  Rashi ibid.  Rashi on Melachim ibid.).  The Zohar even says that the Messiah, son of Yosef, will come from Avi'ah's line (Zohar Chadash 56a).

Yeravam blocked the paths to Yerushalayim and Avi'ah opened them up!  President Trump too has opened up the path to Yerushalayim, and is also the first acting President who ascended to Yerushalayim to visit the Kotel. Perhaps he has a spark of King Avi'ah within him...?

God Bless America

The Holy One, Blessed be He, does not withhold the reward due to any person, and the Holy One, Blessed be He, does not withhold the reward due to America.
America has performed a great act by publicly declaring that Yerushalayim is ours, that she is our capital.
After the Balfour Declaration, Maran Ha-Rav Kook was invited to a ceremony expressing gratitude to Britain.  He said: I am not coming to thank Britain.  They did not give us something which belonged to them, for the Land of Israel is already ours.  Rather I am coming to bless Britain, since anyone who helps the Nation of Israel is deserved of blessing.
And now we have arrived at Balfour Declaration #2 or November 29th #2 (the date on which the UN General Assembly voted in favor of the establishment of the State of Israel): Yerushalayim!
America has acted in contrast to those who ignore the fact that Yerushalayim is mentioned 666 times in the Tanach, and in contrast to the words of the prophet Zechariah (12:3): "And it will come to pass on that day that I will make Yerushalayim a stone of burden for all peoples, all who burden themselves with it will be sorely wounded." And so we say to America: “Yashar Koach!”
Even more so, we say “Yashar Koach” to our Prime Minister, Mr. Binyamin Netanyahu, who has led this process with strength and courage, determination and faith.  May Hashem lengthen his days and his stewardship of our Nation.

And as it says in the first stanza of “God Bless America”: Let us all be grateful for a land so fair.

Also published here:

Short & Sweet - Text Message Q&A #341

Trump as Reincarnation of Koresh
Q: Is it true that President Trump is a reincarnation of Koresh, King of Persia?
A: Nonsense.

Product with Kosher Certification of Badatz and Not the Chief Rabbinate
Q: What is the Halachah regarding a product with Kosher certification of Badatz but not the Chief Rabbinate?
A: There is a law in the State of Israel that a product - whether produced in Israel or imported - must have the Kosher certification of the Chief Rabbinate.  After that, one may add a further Kosher certification.  It once happened that a restaurant opened in the Old City of Yerushalayim with Kosher certification from a Badatz and not from the Chief Rabbinate.  Ha-Rav Avigdor Neventzal, Rav of the Old City, prohibited eating there.  The owner of the restaurant took Rav Neventzal to a Beit Din, but the Rav won, since not having certification from the Chief Rabbinate is forbidden according to the law.  In general, we must have an organization which oversees all products, otherwise there will be all sorts of certifications and we will not know what is Kosher and what is not.  In theory, any product with any Kosher certification is presumed to be acceptable until proven otherwise. We rely on the principle of "Chazakah – presumption" based on the Gemara in Niddah (15b) that a Torah scholar "does not allow food to leave his domain without its Kashrut being ensured."  In communal matters, however, we must have one clear authority in order to avoid problems.  

Learning Gemara
Q: Why do we learn Gemara?  It seems irrelevant for us.
A: It is serving Hashem with our intellect by elevating our own human intellect to a Divine level, according to our ability (See at length in Ha-Rav's book "Chayei Olam").

Q: Is Judaism a Nation, religion or set of character traits?
A: All of these.

Visiting Glorious Belz Shul in Yerushalayim
Q: Is it permissible to visit a Shul, such as the glorious Belz Shul in Yerushalayim, to see its beauty?
A: In general, it is forbidden, since we should not stroll around a Shul.  Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 151:1.  But it is permissible if one says a verse from the Torah while there, and thereby utilizes the place for a holy purpose (See Tzedakah U-Mishpat Chapter 12 note #10). 

Pass the Salt
Q: It is true that one should not pass the salt shaker from one hand to another?
A: Nonsense.

Kosher Supervisor Davening with a Minyan
Q: Is it permissible to work as a Kosher supervisor if, because of the work, one is unable to Daven with a Minyan?
A: It is permissible.  1. One who is involved with a Mitzvah is exempt from another Mitzvah.  2. He is saving Jews from eating Treif (This same ruling is found in Shut Migdalot Merkachim, Yoreh Deah #27). 

Greek Mosaic
Q: How is it possible that there is a mosaic adorned with the Greek sun god in the ancient Shul in Tiveria?
A: Jews who assimilated into Greek culture.

Conquering Eretz Yisrael
Q: What is the difference between our Mitzvah to conquer Eretz Yisrael and the Mitzvah of the Muslims to conquer the entire world?

A: The entire world is not theirs and Eretz Yisrael belongs to us.

Short & Sweet - Text Message Q&A #340

Aristotle's Letter to Alexander the Great
Q: I saw a letter which Aristotle sent to Alexander the Great in which he regrets his learning and says that rather than learning philosophy, which is nonsense, it is preferable to learn Torah.  How do we relate to this letter?
A: There is no proof of authenticity. 

Picture of Rabbenu Ha-Rav Tzvi Yehudah on the Cover of Sichot Ha-Rav Tzvi Yehudah
Q: Why was the picture of Rabbenu Ha-Rav Tzvi Yehudah removed from the new edition of Sichot Ha-Rav Tzvi Yehudah?
A: Because the essence is the content.  For example, there is no picture of the Rambam on a Rambam… (In his eulogy for the Admor of Tosh, Ha-Rav Shlomo Yunger, Dayan of Chasidei Tosh in Kiryat Yoel, related that one of the Chasidim of Ha-Admor R' Yudale of Dizikov once brought him a picture of his grandfather, Ha-Admor Ahavat Yisrael of Viznitz, and wanted to give it to him since he knew how much he was connected to his grandfather.  When he showed him the picture, R' Yudale got upset and yelled that this was not a picture of his grandfather!  He went over to the bookshelf and took out the book Chovot Ha-Levavot and opened it up to the chapter on Perishut (abstention from improper practices), and said to him: This is a picture of my holy grandfather! (Zechor Na, p. 61).

Food Facing the Holy of Holies
Q: People place water and candies in the prayer area facing the Holy of Holies in the Kotel Tunnels and say that it is a Segulah for good health.  Is this true?
A: Certainly not.  One should repent, pray and give Tzedakah.

Braille in Geniza
Q: Do Sifrei Kodesh written in Braille require being placed in a Geniza?
A: No.  This is not the type of script the Torah was discussing.  There are Poskim, however, who do require them to be placed in a Geniza, since this is a type of lettering which many people consider to be a script (Ginzei Kodesh 10:3 #19 in the name of Ha-Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv).  But the basis Halachah is that one can be lenient.

Putting on Talit and Tefillin at Home
Q: Is one obligated to put on Talit and Tefillin at home and go to Shul while wearing them?
A: It is a great practice.  Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 25:2.  But if it is major difficulty, one is not obligated to do so.  And some put them on in the courtyard or lobby of the Shul.  See Piskei Teshuvot 25:6 (The Mishnah Berurah [25:10] in the name of the Magen Avraham [#5], however, writes that in a place where there are non-Jews in the street one should put on the Talit and Tefillin in the Shul courtyard if possible.  In the book "Be-Mechitzat Rabbenu" p. 82, it is related that Ha-Rav Yaakov Kamentzky, Rosh Yeshiva of Torah Ve-Da'at in Brooklyn, was unhappy about people in America walking to Shul in their Talit.  He said that we must remember that we are still in the Exile among the non-Jews and we should not walk in the street as if we own the place.  It seems that during the course of the Exile, we became accustomed not to follow this practice and continued in this way even on our return to Eretz Yisrael.  The book "Chiko Mamtakim" Volume 2 [p. 334] relates that in his later years, Ha-Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach was on his way to the Shul "Kehal Chasidim" in the Sha'arei Chesed neighborhood in Jerusalem, where he lived, and saw a poster that advocated reinstituting the ancient custom of going to Shul wearing Talit and Tefillin.  Many people walked past the sign without any recognition that the announcement was intended for them.  The next day, the residents of the neighborhood were surprised to see Ha-Rav Auerbach walking through Sha'arei Chesed on his way to Shul wearing Talit and Tefillin.  He continued this practice until his passing).

Signaling to a Person Driving on Shabbat to Turn on His Lights
Q: Is it permissible to signal to a person driving on Shabbat that his lights are off?
A: Yes, since it is a potentially life-threatening situation.  And even if he is within a city, where there are lights, it is permissible since perhaps he will leave the city.

Ashkenazim Naming after Living Grandfather
Q: According to the custom of Ashekenzim, is it forbidden to name a child after a living grandfather or is it just customary to refrain from doing so?
A: It is customary to refrain from doing so.  There were Tzadikim, however, such as the Noam Elimelech, who asked their children to name their children after them while they were still living (In Shut Minchat Eleazar [4:27 at the end], the Admor of Munkatch relates that the Noam Elimelech asked his niece to name her son "Elimelech" after him [her son became the famous Bnei Yissaschar and the great-great grandfather of the Admor of Munkatch].  When the child was three years old, when the child came to visit the Noam Elimelech, he was told that the child's name was "Tzvi Elimelech", and he was displeased that they had added a name to his name).

Expelling Communities in Yesha
Q: How should we act during times when communities are being expelled?
A: This is not the question.  Rather we should ask how to influence the Nation's opinion so that there will not be an expulsion.  This is similar to discussing plans for a burial when a person is ill instead of discussing how to keep him alive.    

Q: How do we know if a Midrash is real or a parable?

A: According to the commentators.

Arthur Marcus ztz"l - The Man of Great Chesed

Appeared in the Jewish Press:


Arthur Marcus ztz"l - The Man of Great Chesed

Ha-Rav Shlomo Aviner,

Rosh Yeshivat Ateret Cohain in the Old City of Yerushalayim

Few people in Eretz Yisrael heard of Arthur Marcus, Avraham Zev ben Moshe Yitzchak ztz"l, despite his great merits.  The reason was not only the fact that he lived in America, but on account of his humility and modesty.
Forty years ago, this man established the Central Fund of Israel, which allowed transferring donations to Israel, and to receive a tax-exemption, which is essential for donors there.  Everything was obviously performed in full accordance with the law.  The donor transfers the donation to the fund, and the money is passed along to a non-profit organization in Israel.
In this way, he transferred close to 20 million dollars a year to 300 non-profit organizations.
He did all of this on his free time, together with his wife, who was with him in this holy work.  He worked tens of hours each week, without receiving a penny for himself, and even paid for the expenses from his own money.  At the beginning, he did not even have an office, but rather did everything from his home.  Much later, he did have an office, which was his private office at work.
He did not distinguish between people, but rather transferred donation to any cause which had an idealistic purpose: humanitarian aid, educational institutions, communal projects, Shuls, Yeshivot, projects to build Eretz Yisrael, medical and security projects.  And he did not distinguish between different parts of our Land.  In his eyes, the Shomron and Tel Aviv and the Negev were all the same.  
This reminds us of the three great wealthy men who displayed self-sacrifice for Israel during a time of distress: Nadimon Ben Gurion, Ben Kalba Savu'a and Ben Tzitzit Ha-Keshet.  Arthur Marcus ztz"l however was not wealthy himself, but nonetheless succeeded in transferring hundreds of millions of dollars.  Regarding such things we say: "The act is greater than the one who performs it".  And this was all done in simple and modest ways.
We owe a great debt of gratitude to this great man, and all of those who faithfully busy themselves with the needs of the community, may Hashem grant them a reward, both them and their families, and may they lay in their resting places in peace, with all of the Tzadikim.